Banner
Workflow

The present definition of consent is couched in a language of negation, creates a problem in sexual assault cases

Contact Counsellor

The present definition of consent is couched in a language of negation, creates a problem in sexual assault cases

  • Consent is not parochial. It hinges on an active and conscious exercise of freedom and the ability to make a choice that is bereft of coercion.
  • It is not a blanket immunity given to a series of acts but a form of reassurance given by you to your partner for each of the acts.

Importance of consent

  • Antithesis of rape
  • Nuances of consent need to be explored in rape & sexual assault.
  • Not vitiated by circumstances eroding freedom of choice
  • Substitution of the expression “free and voluntary consent” with an opaque “consent” recommended.

Global context

  • United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW)
  • Recommended that the definition of rape in domestic legislation be amended to make lack of consent a central requirement.
  • Proposed a new definition of consent that mandates an “unequivocal and voluntary agreement” necessitating proof of steps taken by the accused to ascertain whether the complainant was consenting.
  • California, 2014
  • Adopted an affirmative consent standard
  • Defined as “affirmative, conscious, and voluntary agreement to engage in sexual activity”.
  • Australia’s Queensland, 2022
  • Submitted a report based on the experience of women and girls to amend its existing laws on rape.
  • Recommended the new law include affirmative consent laws.

Affirmative consent

  • “Informed, voluntary, and active through the demonstration of clear words or actions” wherein a person has given their permission to engage in consensual sexual activity.
  • Specifies that such affirmative consent can be withdrawn at any time.

Conclusion

  • It is time India moved to an affirmative definition of consent. Such a definition would aid in plugging the loopholes that appear in the present definition of consent which is couched in a language of negation.
  • The need of the hour is, therefore, a law that places a premium on consent as the deciding factor.

Prelims Takeaway

  • CEDAW

Categories